Personally I think the RAT is one of the greatest boots ever made and Danner was sent to this world by God himself...
However everyone has different feed. Boot manufactures all work off the last that they think is the ideal last and thus each fit different. you really need to try several manufacturers to see what is best for you. A good store will measure your feet and how you walk find what is best REI will do this, I think redwings does as well. there are other factors like leather quality, thinkness, sole composition etc
Also Bates are fucking garbagr